The Catcher in the Rye: The meaning of the Nuns and James lock By Alie Yu The Catcher in the Rye by J. D. Salinger is a novel narrating the story the Holden Caulfield, a troubled teenager that is in search of an escape native the flaws that society. After ~ leaving his boarding school and traveling aimlessly because that days, he decides come visit his small sister, Phoebe. ~ above his arrival, Phoebe realizes the he has been kicked out of school and begins to hound him with questions. As soon as Phoebe asks that to name one thing that that likes, Holden immediately thinks of 2 nuns that he freshly met, and also a previous classmate named James Castle.

You are watching: Catcher in the rye james castle

My object is, “When inquiry by Phoebe what that likes, Holden have the right to only think of the nuns and James Castle. Why carry out you intend he thinks of this people? ”. Throughout the novel, Holden struggles with the concept of the “phoniness” that society. The believes the all adults room deceiving, materialistic human being who only act in greed and conceit. Holden thinks that youngsters are practically the just “non-phonies” in the world, and he desire to protect against them native maturing into adulthood. He just respects children and also those that prove to be selfless, compassionate, and always stay true to themselves.

As a result, when he is request what the likes, Holden thinks about the nuns and James Castle. These numbers are among the few people the Holden admires and acknowledges as “non-phonies”. Holden meets the nuns a few days prior to he access time Phoebe. While eating breakfast in ~ the Grand central Station, the nuns sit next to him, and also they strike up a conversation. They are dressed in a dark, homely fashion, and also they speak openly around their professions and interests. That learns the they are working as schoolteachers. The nuns treat him in a sort manner, and thank the profusely once he decides to donate to their charity basket.

Holden compare the nuns v phony world in his life, such as his aunt and Sally Haye’s mother. The knows that neither the these world would be ready to occupational as selflessly and generously together the nuns. Holden respects the nuns for being compassionate and diligent in what lock do, and for working for good causes also though there are not countless benefits for themselves. The is impression by their absence of greed for money and also attention, and also they subsequently join the perform of what Holden likes. James lock was Holden’s ahead classmate at among his former schools, Elkton Hills.

After he called a famous boy conceited, he was bullied by a large group of boys in an effort to do him apologize. James was standing his ground, and also instead the apologizing and also taking earlier his words, the jumped the end of the window. Holden was substantially traumatized by this event, but he was additionally deeply amazing by james’s defiance and strong will. Instead of phonily asking for forgiveness, he stuck by his opinion and also refused to give in. By killing himself rather of to express repentance, James castle was committing the can be fried act of remaining true come himself.

See more: How Many Minutes In A Month Of 30 Days To Minutes, Convert 30 Days To Minutes

For this reason, Holden holds him in high regard and also considers the to it is in a building person. In conclusion, Holden thinks of the nuns and also James Castle when asked what the likes, because he admires them greatly. Holden respects non-phony people, meaning people who carry out not action in a false manner in order to success in society. The nuns work benevolently, even though they do not receive lot in return. Likewise, James castle refused to apologize, also though he was being bullied and tormented. Holden hates all of culture save these individuals. These human being act as Holden’s role models and heroes, and also he unconsciously holds them dear.



The typical student needs to read dozens of books per year. No one has time to check out them all, however it’s essential to go over lock at the very least briefly. Luckily, uses study travel guide on over 1000 top publications from students’ curricula!